Crumbly soap Dec 20, 2024. Ruined What causes crumbly, chalky soap? This is a classic sign of lye heavy soap, i. A batch that has “seized” or become a solid chunk very quickly – This is usually because of the addition of something that soaks up the oil quickly, like clay, or an essential or fragrance oil that Pros of rebatching . Using more firm oils and butters in your recipe will result 278 Likes, TikTok video from ASMR Euphoria 💕 (@asmr_euphoria7): “ASMR Crushing New Year’s Crumbly Soap Balls | Relaxing Brain Cells 💙🩵🤍 #oddlysatisfying #soapcrushingasmr #soapasmr #asmr #asmrvideo #asmrsoapballs #asmrsounds SEE MORE 👇 @ASMR Euphoria 💕 @ASMR Euphoria 💕”. K. Too much sodium lactate, salt or dry goods (like clays). I’ve noticed the same results when using it in cold process soap. Hey there soap experts, I'm looking for help as I'm somewhat stumped. If it’s from a soap supply shop it should be soap stable and stay the right colour. Just for fun, we cut into each soap. Well, in my opinion these are the most common soapmaking problems that you will most likely face in your This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. This is especially common in soap that has partially gelled. I wish I had melted the plain soap first and then SLOWLY added the colored soap – “slowly” meaning a small amount at a time because the colored soap was soap heavily colored that now I have a batch of less heavily colored soap but still too heavily colored I made a soap that it cracked on the top like a cobblestone pavement and when I took it out of the molds it broke up and it also expanded in the mold (I actually used two different molds and the single mold is the one it raised out of it a Rebatching soap is the process of melting down existing soap and turning it into a new soap. New posts New media New media comments Latest activity. I'm pretty sure I used too much, because when I began to slice the log into bars it sort of wanted to crumble. Joined Mar 21, 2013 Messages 89 Reaction score 52. 3. Although the recipe is highly cleansing and unlike anything I’ve made, I’ve noticed that all of these fats have a tendency to get brittle as single oil soaps. Read More That could be the reason it is crumbly. Thread starter Sunibee; Start date Dec 5, 2021; Help Support Soapmaking Forum: This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others. Getting ready to post a pic on the BB Facebook page! Most lye calculators default to a water content that is suitable for hot process soap making. Soaping cool (100 °F or below) can increase the chance of soda ash. FWIW, the one time I got something crumbly in the soap (a few blobs in the middle), the crumbly areas zapped for a few days, then didn't. Powdery, Crumbly Soap: An Emulsion Issue! * Do you see a difference between the pink mixed soap in pics 2 and 3? What do you think? You unmold your handmade soap and it’s soft and a bit This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. M. Reply. From left to right: Exhibit A, Exhibit B, Exhibit C. Hot process soap is heated, This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. Soap is soft and crumbly. Now after a few weeks. any other ideas are welcome . I've been reading of people making this exact recipe by cooking for as little as 20 minutes and as long as 2 hours. Crumbly hot process soap what went wrong. elizab1998; Nov 2, 2024; Recipe Feedback; Replies 4 Views 378. 🙂 Yesterday i made 2 batch of soap. Heat the mixture until the shea butter is melted. Hard and crumbly. When it softens to that cheddar cheese texture, remove the soap from the oven and try to make a cut, preferably with a flat blade (bench scraper), not I recommend mixing some more liquid-like oils into your recipe. This week I made a beautiful olive oil+coconut oil+coco butter soap and added too much clay. 1. In hot processed soap making you need additional water because the heat causes some of the water to evaporate. This stretches each bar of soap by minimizing exposure to excess water. Okay, so my understanding of salt soap is that they get very hard very quick and it’s best to un-mold within 4-12 hours and cut it soon after. Learn why homemade soap becomes crumbly and how to fix it with rebatching or adjusting the recipe. The baking process, at a low temperature, is crucial in ensuring that the soap is well blended and thoroughly cured. Zing. These websites also usually show photos of the mica in a bar of soap as an example of what it will really look like to help This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. one of the posters told they were using roebic brand. Palm Oil is known to separate in its container. 5% coconut and palm, 25% olive, 10% mango butter and avocado oil. From the lightness of the colors as well as your comment that the soap is soft and crumbly, I suspect your soap simply didn't get warm enough to gel. Following that information I entered 33% water in soapcalc instead of 38% and it reached It also helps to soap cool. 56 / Fl Oz) Step 2: In a separate heat-safe container, combine the sunflower oil, coconut oil, and shea butter. S $17. If your soap has a crumbly texture, ensure it is not lye heavy. Bonding Layers. Never had it accelerate, rice, seize, nothing. Just be careful that you don’t use too much sodium lactate or it can cause your soap to go crumbly. I'm sorry for my bad english. This is an example of deep soda ash – notice the crumbly texture. Jun 9, 2022 #1 I had a bunch of soap scraps and decided to rebatch them into some soap for my family. Share: Facebook X (Twitter) Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Share Link. I'm using the same formula but different addictive (fragrance, mica and natural . Sodium Lactate. Reason: Too much sodium lactate can cause the soap to become hard and crumbly. Help Support Soapmaking Forum: I failed my soap twice in 2 days. Instead of using the entire bar of soap in one go, cut the bar into smaller chunks to make soap last longer. Add to the lye This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. Castile soap takes much longer to come to ‘Trace’ than other soap recipes. Crumbly soap can be caused by any number of things, some of the reasons include the soap being too lye heavy or even just from soaping at cooler temperatures. I cut one slice and it was pretty crumbly and dry. Check zap. What I do recall is that I left it to cure after cutting, crumbles and all, and found out that that cure (or just leaving it alone) somehow eliminated the crumbling. Reply reply Thank You Credit: Slow Cooker Rebatch Video by Soaping 101 Here is how I Rebatch, step-by-step: Rebatch Prep. Walfos Soap Mold for soap Making, Soap Making kit - 42 oz Silicone Loaf soap Mold Set with Rectangular Wood Box & Bamboo Cutter Measuring Box, 2 Scraper for Soaps Making Walfos-US $24. Aug 14, 2009 #1 This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. In use the crumbly bits wore away and the rest of the bar was fine. And you’re positive I've done 3 batches using vinegar as part of my liquid to produce sodium acetate (1% oil weight) in order to make the bars harder and improve lather, but all three of them are crumbly when I'm cutting them. I'm from indonesia. And you’re positive that you added enough lye. Lard Recipe. Dry and crumbly. It usually forms within 1-3 days. Its my first time using sodium lactate on my soap. Making soap can be a relaxing event, especially when you have an idea in your head and cant wait to see the final product. These 3 problem batches were made with roebic crystals. The soap is developing ‘soda ash’/a white powdery substance. . Soap with a dry, crumbly texture could be caused by too much lye in your recipe. The most common form of Rebatched soap, also known as hand-milled soap or French-milled soap, is essentially a process of recycling soap to improve its consistency and performance. All of the recipes had a high percentage of hard Powdery, Crumbly Soap: An Emulsion Issue Soapmaking Tips, Soapmaking Troubleshooting. Crumbly soap dough. Hard to say. Divide it up. goodness follow @satisoap for more. If it is brittle and hard, it can also crumble when cut, but I don't get the feeling that's the problem here especially since this recipe More than likely you've cut it too late. Another friend texted me with a picture of some really crumbly unsaponified soap that was a real mess. Większość moich filmów to nie mówiące filmy, więc spodziewaj się w How To Make amish crumbly homemade soap. 99 ($0. I'm impressed that there was no zap, and yet the soap burned. original sound - ASMR Euphoria 💕. Coconut creates lather but also can be very drying so use it with caution, it may be too drying for you, or not at all. It did not gel though, and they weren’t deep cracks. There are two characteristics that lead me to believe it is caused by titanium dioxide: the crumbly/chalky texture of the white portion and the translucent yellow bordering the white, which are glycerin rivers. Step 3: Slowly pour the lye mixture into the oil mixture while stirring continuously until it reaches a medium trace. Hi everyone! I know this has been addressed before, but I thought it couldn't hurt to ask again. Crumbly soap! Thread starter emilaid; Start date Oct 21, 2009; Help Support Soapmaking Forum: 5. But if the soap is 60% hard oils, it could be ready to unmold the next day. You can tell if a soap is lye-heavy if, after a few days of curing time, it still registers a pH of 10. One other thing that may have an impact, was the lye took forever to disolve into the water, and I'm not sure if there's a timecrunch between transfering the lye into the oil mixture. Indeed, I usually don't see ALL the phases the batter is supposed to reach. This is a tell-tale sign of too much fat in your soap. I realised it still breaking in the centre. The rest of the soap in that batch was OK (i. You added enough lye. Miss Elaine Member. Start by taking your soap to be rebatched and breaking it down into tiny pieces. Your soap could be crumbly because it did not go through gel phase. 99 Walfos Soap Mold for soap Making, Soap Making kit - 42 oz Silicone Loaf soap Mold Set with Rectangular Wood Box & Bamboo Cutter Measuring Crumbly soap is totally par for the course with salt – that’s why we recommend cutting quickly =) I hope that you were able to get some good cuts from that. This could be because of two reasons. I had another batch that just turned out kind of ugly. Soap made a few hours ago is turning darker in the middle and looking funny: Reason: This is a normal part of the soapmaking process called gel phase, which is when the chemical reaction between the lye and oils causes the soap to heat up hotter than it was when This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. High-quality glycerin soap shouldn't crumble, but over time it can dry out if not tightly sealed. Just search up soap supply websites in your area and buy off those. Now I wonder if that’s correct. I usually soap closer to 100. Another thing worth mentioning I have recently changed brands of lye. If your soap crumbles when cutting or appears dry and powdery, it is likely that the soap is too lye-heavy. Crumbly and dry looking rather like laundry detergent powder is usually the result of a batch that is lye heavy. New posts Search forums. The easiest way I have found to do this is with a cheese grater. I used EDTA too though This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. Lye was at 89 F and oils at 95. Make sure to recalculate the lye amount if you change the oil amounts. Homemade soap will crumble or break apart if your soap mixture was lye heavy. Troubleshoot recipe, make needed adjustments, address the issue of how much oil was missing and add that back when remelting. Thus the whole container needs to be heated up before Speaking of leaving crumbly soap longer: Early in my soap making journey, I made a soap that was really crumbly like yours (not a salt bar, & I don't really recall what it was now). By carefully weighing the soap and adding water, it’s possible to bring the soap back to it’s natural texture. Uneven Cuts: Also adding a bit too much salt in the lye water can make your soap hard enough to have crumbly edges. DrewsSoaps; Oct 7, 2024; Lye-Based Soap Forum; Replies 14 Views 925. Ultimately, the thickness of the blade has pushed the bottom edge of the soap away from the surface because it's easier for the soap to crack and break than for the soap to move away from the blade as you slice through (it's not much of an effect - this would happen more with a wedge shaped knife). It doesn’t zap, so it isn’t lye heavy. Lye-heavy soaps also tend to become very hard and crumbly very quickly in the mold, but this is not always the case. It was like breaking chucks of chocolate that has been in the freezer. Another thing to consider is the recipe itself. My soap is kinda soft and crumbly (gonna wait to cut) but I did similar things to you, 35% lard soap, soaped hot around 120. S $29. I want to rebatch it to new soap . Soap is crumbly and DRY. I made, for the first time, a CPHP batch of: 52 oz tallow (hand made with 3 tbs salt/lb 7 oz lye 20. I speak in indonesia n javanese everyday. What's new. ) 2. Mayra Abshire IV. coz this is a triple butter Crumbly soap. Thread starter MarnieSoapien; Start date Feb 12, 2019; Help Support Soapmaking Forum: crumbly purple degree soap!! credit @soapy. I recommend starting with 1-2% and going up from there. Brittle Crumbly Soap. Different tribes who manufacture these soaps have typical their own african black soap recipes that make the final product in varying quality, however, the purest form of these soaps are produced in Ghana. Body Butter Fomula feedback. When you reach it, it means that the soap batter is fully gelled and it's ready to be poured in the mould. 43 likes, 2 comments - lovinsoapstudio on August 22, 2024: "Powdery, Crumbly Soap: An Emulsion Issue * Do you see a difference between the pink mixed soap in pics 2 and 3? What do you think? You unmold your handmade soap and it’s soft and a bit crumbly. My notes show that my oils and lye were both at 85 degrees F. Make sure you have stired all the liquid from the bottom or you will have to aagh! Made my oatmeal and honey soap (not the first time) but I added more oatmeal this time than usual (toasted and ground). Make NEW SOAP, and add the grated salt bar soap to the new batch at light trace. Solution: Use 1 teaspoon of sodium lactate per pound of oils in a soap recipe. Let stand 10 minutes, then stir again. Also, if soap gets too hot it can crack. It still is a little crumbly though from drying out a bit. Some soapmakers dread it, possibly because they feel they are trying to “save” a batch that failed for various reasons (be it an undesired scent, color, design, or an omission of an ingredient) and don’t want to remember the “fail”. . ) does anyone have a rule of thumb how much clay per pound? B. It can be because you missed out an oil in the recipe. Replies 29 She noted that using too much with a high percentage of hard oils results in a soap that is crumbly and flaky. sprinkle lye in last (very importain) Stir. ashantz18; Nov 12, 2024; Recipe Feedback; Replies 18 Views 1K. If the soap is lye heavy, it will zap. The soap has too much lye in it & is lye heavy. Yikes!! crumbly soap. Crumbly Soap Soap with a dry, crumbly texture could be caused by too much lye in your recipe. It can also be caused by over cooking if you are doing HP. In cold process soap too much water simply makes it soft. Thread starter angiem915; Start date Sep 17, 2014; Help Support Soapmaking Forum: This site may earn a commission from merchant Crumbly soap can be caused by a few things. Thread starter Miss Elaine; Start date Aug 14, 2009; Help Support Soapmaking Forum: This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others. Here are tips and tricks for salvaging powdery, Crumbly Soap I put too much lye in one of my first batches. Use a grater on the finest grate side available. (You'll water out the salt and end up with a giant crumbly mess. My batter was still quite liquid while working this time as opposed to others So when you take only a portion of the separated fatty acids, the amount of lye required would not necessarily be the same as what is required for the homogenized palm oil, meaning you may have lye heavy soap on your hands, and that CAN contribute to a crumbly soap, but there are also other reasons for crumbly soap. Crumbly soaps are usually too hard, and so you possibly should have cut it in 12 - 18 hours. Soap is hard and crumbly: 1. Not sure what I am doing wrong but just going to go back to wrapping in towels and heating pad method. To rebatch soap means to make a new batch of soap with pre-made soap. 575 likes, 1 comments - asmrsoapbee on June 10, 2022: "Crumbly Silk soap, here’s to the weekend 李 #soap#soaplove#soapcrushing#soapcrunching#soaplove#soapsatisfying#soaprelaxing#soapcurls#soapstrips#soaproses#satisfying#relaxing#softsoap#soapcutting#soaplover#soapfun#asmr#soapasmr#asmrlove#vintagesoap#retrosoap#lovesoap#soapplates#Мыло#Мыльныйхруст#Мыльнаялюбовьq". This soap meets the best of both worlds, when an ancient art passed through generation is combine with modern days soapmaking! In this video I included authe In general does crumbly soap mean something specific? Like too much water or cutting too soon? Help! Forums. Link in BIO #asmr #soapsounds #soapcrushing #soaprelax #asmrsoap #satisfying #soapstarch #soapboxeswithstarch #crushingsoap #asmrsoapeuphoria". How to make bath salts that don't clump? (I've tried everything) Bathbombgal; Jun 22, 2024; Bath and Body Forum; Replies 5 Views 2K. With the soap looking brittle like cocoa butter out of the frig, rather than crumbly, false trace seems unlikely to me. 2 months ago I made a batch of soap and divided it into 3 parts to make some scent samples. This can happen if there’s too much lye. Though, my soap was never so crumbly to break in pieces when used. not scraping the dried soap batter off the sides of the cooking pot or the spatula. The method involves grating existing soap bars, melting them down, and then adding additional ingredients such as fragrances, colors, or moisturizers before molding them Tried CPOP’ing again the last couple of batches and both times the bottom and edges of the soap are crumbly. With my 100% CO soaps I cut while still warm, but firm. It may take only 30 minutes. It's actually decently hard, but could be better. If the pH is safe to use, the crumbly texture could also be caused by soaping with cool temperatures. Thread starter Lilway; Start date Jun 9, 2022; Messages 16 Reaction score 40 Location Ohio. October 19, 2011 at 6:00 am. I've also taken to doing heat transfer just to save on time. Mobjack Bay. Thread starter MihiriBubbles; Start date Jul 13, 2022; Help Support Soapmaking Forum: This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others. To check for lye heaviness, tap that soap lightly on your tongue. I un-molded at 5 hours and it was smooth and hard on the outside. The soap did turn out crumbly. 6. Repeat until no zap remains. It’s either going to have to be re-batched, or sent to Clean the World. MomInWA. This was at about 48 hours. Powdery, Crumbly Soap: An Emulsion Issue. since it was just for me, I dug out the blobs and used the soap, and it was not irritating). This soap had pumpkin puree in it, and the mini soapy Crumbly, brittle soap can be the result of too little water, too much lye or too fine a trace. What’s the difference between cold process and hot process soap? Both cold process and hot process soap starts out being mixed the same way. Crumbly Soap. Its not smooth when I pour it, it never seems to get past the applesauce stage (have stirred The Soap Making & Craft Forum. 😱 It doesn’t za | Instagram It can even be soft and crumbly, with the corners breaking off in the mold upon unmolding. 5 oz water It never turned to "thick mashed potatoes" and is crumbly, though after freezing for 1/2 hour, unmolding and letting it sit over night its very hard. Tip: Test the pH of your soap to ensure it’s not caustic. B. I used a recipe given to Crumbly soap is usually a sign of lye heavy soap. If it doesn't, you can still use the soap as is or you can cut the outer crumbly areas away; that is entirely your call. Soap Queen said that soda ash can run all the way through a bar causing crumbly soap so I did wonder if that was the problem, what did we do that caused the ash - we used no clay. I'm always reading that non trace is one of the reasons for crumbly soap, but i would like to know why this is happening? Beautiful soap! I have had crumbling like that from using too much sodium lactate, and for some reason, I can't use sodium lactate in my low slab mold, like yours appears to be, otherwise my soap is always crumbly, I'm not sure why! It's gorgeous soap though, it looks like big slabs of white chocolate Caustic soap. Using less water than what’s typical, is called This one was crumbly on the edges when I cut it. How to prevent soda ash. Soda ash can also make the soap feel crumbly. 5% superfat. After 2 to 3 checks, if your soap is still looking fairly solid, and a little dry, add some extra liquid and give it a gentle stir. This means your soap will be harsh and potentially irritate and burn your skin. My oven is old so not exactly sure if Dried, Crumbly Soap Base. Sunibee Well-Known Member. ) is there any way I can reuse or repurpose this pretty, beautiful smelling, super hard and crumbly soap? Closely related to #2---Distractions in your soap making area can cause you to make mistakes. Rebatching allows you to use ingredients like: In conclusion, rebatching crumbly soap can be a simple process with a few key steps. Joined Oct 9, 2020 Messages 172 Reaction score 113 Location India. I'm doing cphp and it seems every batch (no matter what recipe) turns crumbly. To get two soap layers to adhere, spray rubbing alcohol on the first--hardened--layer before pouring The soap is brittle or crumbly. Kasap; Nov 13, 2024; Lye-Based Soap Forum; Replies 8 1,101 likes, 2 comments - asmr_soap_euphoria on October 5, 2023: "ASMR crumbly soap balls | Watch more videos on my YouTube channel. ewhitake. Stir frequently for the first 1 1/2 hours. Add the essential oil and stir until fully incorporated. Some bars even fractured in two. YES I cut them last night upside down and they did gerat. The soap is pretty crumbly. This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. New media New comments Search media. Lorie says. crumbly soap. Gelling the soap with honey and milk results in some pretty nasty results This leaves free lye in the finished soap and makes it caustic and unsafe for use, even for laundry or cleaning purposes. Hello! I am trying my hand at cold process soap making and decided to attempt a 100% olive oil castile soap. Lastly if your soap is really high in coconut oil it will crumble if you do not cut it asap. Thread Crumbly hot process soap what went wrong. elizab1998; Nov 2, 2024; Recipe Feedback; Replies 4 Views 370. Other problems could include insufficient botanical material, which leaves soap between the herbs to stick together, or crumbly Can someone please help me (hope the pic turns out). I made some soap using a slow moving recipe (link below). If your soap has a crumbly texture, ensure it is not lye heavy. See more Learn how to fix common soapmaking mistakes, such as lye heavy soap, soft soap, cracking tops and more. S. I have a feeling it will be the latter. A soaper goes to unmold a soap and it is soft, a bit crumblyalmost like Playdough. E. I went ahead and used the soap when this happened to me. Soda ash most often forms with lower temperatures and when the soap is poured at thin trace. The butters in combination with palm oil make a really hard, dry, crumbly soap. It doesn’t za" 🫧Powdery, Crumbly Soap: An Emulsion Issue🫧 You unmold your handmade soap and it’s soft and a bit crumbly. Crumbly Soap Edges: Crumbly soap edges can occur when the soap is too dry or cut too late. Soap base containing too much lye can cause crumbly soap, so purchase supplies from a respected supplier. Crumbly soap may be a sign of excess lye in your soap (which is why it’s always a good idea to don gloves when first handling soap!). That is to say more lye than oils to convert. The fragrances, colors, and additives you put in the soap are added after the oils have completely reacted with the lye. A white powdery substance on the soap’s surface isn’t harmful but it can be unsightly. e. Let both mixtures cool to around 100-110°F. First batch soap dishes by casual_haus #soapdish #jesmonitesoapdish ———————— 🎁งานของชำร่วยสบู่ / งานจัดชุดรับไหว้สบู่ สนใจสอบถามทาง Line (link in bio) กับน้องแอดมินได้เลยค่า ———————— 💯handmade #weddingfavors # The soap may take 1 to 1 1/2 hours to become soft enough. AND it The Soap Making & Craft Forum. Soap that goes through gel phase is usually harder upon unmolding and can be unmolded after 24 hours of pouring. Indeed, they're added after most of the saponification process is done – hence the additives aren’t affected by the harsh lye. If it’s caustic, 2) What are some of the causes of soap getting hard and crumbly? One of the primary causes of soap getting hard and crumbly is adding too little water during the soapmaking process. I don't have any ph strips so I do this: Once your soap is a free flowing liquid, dilute 5g in as little water as possible, add it and stir for a while. The soap was still wonderful tho, and people I shared it with loved it! (thanks Amanda!) However, on the second batch I chose to use round PVC pipes for round bars. No zap (so far as we can tell- This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. Unfortunately it will ruin your design but worth the trouble for un-crumbly soap! (See Oven Rebatch) Also, regular Palm Oil may well be the reason the stearic acid settled to the bottom, causing it to crumble when cut, from soaping too cool. An abundance of lye in your recipe will be left without an oil to saponify with, thus showing up as free radical particles. Last week I tried using the same method again – waiting until medium trace – and ended up with 50 bars of partially gelled and crumbly soap. Nov 2, 2024. Joined Jul 3, 2021 Messages 17 Reaction score 38 Location When a batch of mine goes bad, I either rebatch (like you just did) or turn it into liquid soap. It should be Hi. Good luck! 212 likes, 4 comments - lovinsoapstudio on April 4, 2023: "Powdery, Crumbly Soap: An Emulsion Issue You unmold your handmade soap and it’s soft and a bit crumbly. Ungelled soap can be crumbly if it is cut too soon, but ungelled soap is usually softer than gelled soap, and you said that your soap was rock-hard, so that may not be the case here. Find out how to rebatch, test pH, use sodium lactate and fragrance calculator. And its horrible advise to use cups, that page should be taken down. It's a repeated recipe, didn't change a thing, so obviously the non trace made the soap crumble. The reason I mention it is while I was searching the forum I found two other threads about unexplainable crumbly soap. I try to soap around 85-90 degrees F when using milks, beer, wine, etc. Media. However, it could be a recipe problem and I've often found that when i don't gel my soap that it goes crumbly too. MuseLuxe Soap Making Kit for Adults & Beginners - Soap Making Supplies Melt and Pour - Soap Base,Silicone Molds,Soap Loaf Molds,Soap Cutter Box,Fragrances,Gift Card,Soap DIY Craft Kit JINGLC. This creates a chunky soap with different-colored bits throughout. This can cause the soap to harden, it difficult to I soap around 100F. I have a feeling my husband was trying to talk to me when I accidentally omitted the almond oil in my fiasco mentioned above. eyebright Well-Known Member. 4 weeks after soap Crumbly Soap. I'm new to soap making so I read to educate myself. 5-8% is when I starting getting the flaky crumbly results. Too much lye. soapmaker Soapmaker Supporting Member. Soap Volcano: Natural sugars (including fruit purees) and alcohol in cold process soap can super heat the soap and cause what’s known as a soap volcano. I For example, if the soap is made with 100% olive oil, it may take up to two weeks to unmold. You can read about more methods for testing lye heaviness in The texture was rough and almost crumbly. Check the pH at the end of the cure, i. What did I This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. It’s important to measure that your ingredients accurately to prevent a harsh, crumbly bar of soap. Everyone mostly uses mica, the glittery powder to colour soap. This was by far to be my most favorite soap as far as color and scent goes. Adding both can definitely be problematic. | Last update: Tuesday, May 3, 2022. To use melt and pour soap is really a kind of rebatching soap. I read this kind of soap will usually take long to trace and unmold due to it being a soft oil. Soap is crumbly upon un-molding. Crumbly CP Soap. Thread starter rosevalleygirl; Start date Jan 21, 2013; Help Support Soapmaking Forum: Why did my soap turn black? Author: Dr. The salt bar to be grated can be newer soap, or older soap; just grate it as small as possible. Soft and crumbly soap that just wants to Help please. It is still soap and will work just fine, but these bits keep the soap from looking nice and smooth (one of the big objections to HP). It can be made by you or someone else. It worked fine and I didn't have to waste all that soap. Nov 16, 2024. it cut well. I soaped Hi all, I made a batch of soap yesterday and I have about 10 oz leftover from trimming it up. From my research it seems that the issue is either: too little lye (my recipe is about 14% and a soap calculator, assuming I used it correctly, gave me about 18%) or its just needs to cure much longer due to the higher % olive oil After that soap had set for about 10 days, I grated it and made the rebatch soap – half colored soap/half plain soap. But distractions do happen. Too little water in hot process soap will result in hard and crumbly soap. I was cleaning and reorganizing the craft room anyway so figured why not. To avoid crumbles and cracking for my laundry soap, I keep the oils/lye at a low temperature (100-110F), put it in the fridge right after pouring, and cut it after 3-4 hours. Struggling to come up with a pourable HP recipe for birch tar soap. The texture of african black soap is crumbly and it is very soft, it is black to dark brown depending on the recipe. It is about probably 30 hours old now and is crumbly and sticky but will stick and hold if I really squish it together. As the soap becomes smooth (this stage will take a while, up to an hour or more, so try to be patient) don’t Crumbly soap? Hi all, My latest batch of CP was crumbly as I was taking it out of the mold. 99 MuseLuxe Soap Making Kit for Adults & Kids - Soap Making Supplies with Melt and Pour Soap Base,6 Silicone Molds,Soap Colorant,Fragrances,Dried Flowers,Gift To elaborate on this: I think what you’re seeing is a soap with way too much titanium dioxide. Also make sure you make soap at ambient temperatures (32-43C/90-110F) and use adequate water for soapmaking. And every hour for the rest of the day. Perhaps swap one of the butters out for olive oil. 5 yrs. If it “zaps” you, it is lye heavy. Lye-Based Soap Forum. I am new to soap making and upon cutting my 3rd ever batch of soap I found it to be extremely crumbly! I haven't had this problem before, but again I am new to soapmaking. Why is my Rebatch soap crumbly. If you still encounter crumbly edges, try using a sharper cutter and applying a steady, even pressure while cutting. Crumbly soap – Most commonly this is because it wasn’t mixed long enough, or it was made at a temperature that was too low or too high. Joined Aug 3, 2017 Messages Several factors can cause crumbly soap, including lye heaviness or extreme temperature changes. Joined Aug 14, 2009 Messages 12 Reaction score 0. My soap passed the zap test after 1/2 Powdery, Crumbly Soap: An Emulsion Issue! * Do you see a difference between the pink mixed soap in pics 2 and 3? What do you think? You unmold your handmade soap and it’s soft and a bit This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in our Facebook Group, Saponification Nation. I couldn't stand the thought of throwing it out, so I ground it up in the food processor and added washing soda and borax like you do with Fels Naptha to make laundry detergent. 33% lye concentration. Thread starter nettles; Start date A lye heavy soap is more prone to cracking, same with a soap that has a large portion of solid oils/butters. Why rebatch soap? Upping the superfat by adding more oils or butter; Forgotten ingredients like scents or color; Fixing other mistakes like bubbles in the soap Crumbly Rebatch. it happens on soaps without any clays in them, but tends to happen in soaps we pour thinner. This is a first for me and it is devastating!!! I have been extremely lucky up until now with not having any of my soaps do anything weird. Find out if crumbly soap is safe to use and when to avoid it for soap making. Formulation issues. I have made 100% coconut oil cold process liquid soap quite a few times, easily and Forums. GIGITOM; Sep 25, 2024; Recipe Feedback; 2. Lye-Based Soap Forum . This is usually caused by an inaccurate measurement somewhere along the line. Aug 20, 2024. D. Next time cut the soap before it gets so hard. Now I know that you can understand when the soap is ready by checking the translucent stage. there is too much sodium hydroxide for the quantity of oils. I used 2% sodium lactate instead of 1% like usual from the recipe calculator amount given. I've had a lot of softer soaps because of my water content but this felt different. The problem with trying to diagnose someone else's soaping problems is that there are so many variables. The soap didn't separate, didn't zap at the crumbly part, all of the other part is darker and had passed through gel phase. I dont use that much almond, i usually keep it in the 10% but thats just me. If you’ve had bad luck with crumbly soap while cutting, check out our article for tips on how to cut a bar of soap Witam, jestem Magda! Tworzę filmy ASMR, które pomogą Ci się zrelaksować i być może zasnąć. Same exact recipe that I did not CPOP came out of the mold beautifully and is smooth as glass. Thread starter ShySoaper; Start date Jun 1, 2020; Help Support Soapmaking Forum: This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others. 27. (like pieces just breaking off the edges) So my questions I am new to this forum, making soap about 6 months and candles for about 2. Are you using additives? Let us know if so, and maybe we can help diagnose a bit more. Crumbly soap. I made 100% OO soap 2000 grms OO 620 gr water 257 gr lye 58 gr combination of mint EOs RT OO and just slightly warm lye (hand on the outside of the pot) It firmed up really fast for OO soap and now is crumbling when I cut it. 59K subscribers in the soapmaking community. The plan is to divide and conquer (the bar of soap, that is). Sodium acetate , sodium citrate and a pinch of table salt will give me salts migrating out of the soap resulting in hard sometimes crumbly edges. Post reply Insert quotes Similar threads. As far as the crumbly edges, I have found that it may or may not go away over time. SIX: When the entire batch is fully consistent in texture and color (no oil leaking, no strange looking globby spots) and the batch is sticking together in the pot in a smooth and homogenous manner, you are ready to glop. As the soap completes the gel phase, the process is reversed with the edges cooling and My soap was crumbly n i rebatched it thinking it needed extra cooking. Forgetting to zero your scales after putting Rebatching soap is the process of melting down existing soap and turning it into a new soap. Liquid soap is easy to neutralize with citric acid. This is an issue that I’ve seen many times in [] By Amanda Aaron | 2020-12-07T08:55:41-06:00 December 5, 2020 | Soapmaking Tips, Soapmaking Troubleshooting | 4 Comments. A subreddit to discuss the art of Soap Making. A. It doesn’t zap, so we know it isn’t lye heavy. 53 votes, 24 comments. The center is solid and hard but the edges are crumbly. It cracked on top after 24 hours. The Soap Making & Craft Forum. The only difference is that cold process soap doesn’t have extra heat applied, so needs 24 to 48 hours in a mold to finish the saponification process (the chemical reaction of soapmaking). The cut bar broke into 2 pieces. To prevent this, monitor your soap’s curing time and cut when it reaches the ideal firmness. If your soap does not go through gel phase, you might wait an extra 24-48 hours before unmolding. White layer formed on soap bar. Haven't tried to cut it and hope that a little more time will address the soft crumbles. When my soap doesn't gel, it has the same characteristics. I did a combination of both. It's essential to weigh your ingredients precisely and mix them thoroughly to obtain a trace. Creamy Castile Soap - Crumbly and Partially Gelled Cold processed, six days later and the soap is still very soft, crumbly and almost fluffy. MihiriBubbles Member.
rlzrl kvbu lwezoqp bwgu camob cqhig agozpt xtvjwv gzzkcs fda